BMS for Mosque Ras Ghurab Island
General Authority for Islamic Affairs and Endowments Crown Prince Court Emirates of Abu Dhabi
Guide
Most building management systems in this region are installed correctly and commissioned badly. The difference shows up in the electricity bill about a year later.
The real failure mode
The common ending for a building management system in the UAE is not a breakdown. It is an operator who could not get the schedules to behave, put the air handling units into hand, and left them there. The graphics still work. The head end still shows a building. The building is simply no longer being managed by it.
That happens because commissioning is the part of a BMS contract most often compressed when a handover date slips. Cabling, panels and point installation are visible and get inspected. Whether the chilled water valve actually modulates in response to the space temperature, and whether the schedule survives a power cycle, are not visible and frequently do not get proved.
Almafor installs and commissions BMS as part of a wider controls scope, on mosques, learning centres, industrial buildings and mixed developments in Abu Dhabi. The list below is what we would check if we were buying one.
Scope
The term is used loosely, and two bidders can price very different systems under the same three letters. Pin down which of these are in scope.
Air handling units, fan coil units, chillers, pumps and the sequencing between them. This is the part everybody prices. It is also where the energy is, so it is where commissioning quality pays back.
Reading main and sub metering into the same head end, so consumption can be attributed to a floor, a tenant or a plant item. Frequently descoped early and expensive to add later.
Lighting control zones and schedules, plus monitored interfaces to fire alarm and Civil Defence systems. Interfaces are usually monitoring only, and the boundary should be written down rather than assumed.
The workstation, the graphics, alarms, trends and reports. Ask to see graphics from a delivered job rather than a brochure, and ask who owns the licence when the contract ends.
Before you sign
Track record
A mosque, an oil and gas learning centre, an industrial development and a manufacturing plant. Different building types, same discipline.
General Authority for Islamic Affairs and Endowments Crown Prince Court Emirates of Abu Dhabi
Schlumberger Technical Services Inc.
China – UAE Industrial Capacity Cooperation (JIANGSU) Development and Management LTD
Al Tala Board Manufacturing Company Ltd
Platforms
Open protocols matter more than brand on a BMS, because they decide whether your next contractor can work on it.
Common questions
It scales with point count rather than floor area, which is why two buildings of the same size can differ by a factor of three. The more useful question at tender stage is what the price per point includes: whether commissioning of each loop, seasonal revisits and operator training are in it, or whether they arrive later as variations.
In practice they are used interchangeably in this region. Building management system is the more common term in UAE tender documents; building automation system is more common in North American specifications. Neither tells you anything about what is actually in scope, so read the points list.
Yes, and it is a large part of this work. The first step is a survey of what is genuinely connected versus what is on the drawings, because the two rarely match on a system that has been through a few years of tenant fit outs. Undocumented changes are the normal condition.
Preferably not. A system built on open protocols such as BACnet and Modbus can be extended or maintained by somebody other than the original installer. A closed system is cheaper on day one and more expensive for the rest of its life, and that trade is worth making deliberately rather than by accident.
Yes. We have delivered centralised energy and water metering and monitoring as its own scope as well as inside a BMS. If metering is likely to be wanted later it is much cheaper to allow for it in the original points list than to retrofit it.
Related
Tell us about the system you need built, upgraded or kept running.